Order Your Holiday Turkeys and Pies

Pumpkin pie

We are now taking orders for fresh, Vermont turkeys and Co-op made pies until Monday, Nov. 16.
There are three ways to place your turkey order: Fill out our online turkey order form (please fill out separate forms for more than one turkey), call us at (802) 223-8000, or order in person at the customer service desk.

For the safety of our shoppers during COVID-19, we have updated our turkey pickup procedure. Please read carefully:

You will receive an email order confirmation after placing your order. We will email you a detailed pickup reminder by Nov. 17.

Turkey pickup will take place under the tent in the Vermont State Colleges parking lot at 575 Stone Cutters Way, Montpelier on Sunday and Monday, Nov. 22 and 23 from 10 am to 6 pm and Tuesday and Wednesday, Nov. 24 and 25 from 8 am to 7 pm.

When picking up, please stay in your car. A staff member will greet you and locate, price, and bring your turkey and pie to you.

Have your debit or credit card ready for payment. If you prefer to pay with cash or check, once you have your turkey, you will need to move your car into our parking lot and pay inside the store.

Picking up your turkey and pie can be combined with your Curbside Pick-Up order for the safest possible shopping experience. Select a Curbside Pick-Up time that matches our turkey and pie pick-up times (see days and times listed above), and we will have your Curbside Pick-up order waiting for you at our turkey tent.

Pricing and Turkey Information

Not sure what size you need? Here is our recommended serving size per person:
3/4 lb for no leftovers
1 lb for a small amount of leftovers
1 1/2 lbs for hearty eaters or ample leftovers
2 lbs for hearty eaters and leftovers

Our fresh turkeys will be coming from two Vermont farms:

Misty Knoll Farms is a family-owned farm in New Haven, featuring turkeys that are humanely raised and given a vegetarian feed that contains no antibiotics or animal byproducts. They provide their turkeys with room to roam in a natural, stress-free environment and raise their birds with a high level of care at every step.
Misty Knoll Farms turkeys are $3.49/lb for member-owners and $3.99/lb for nonmembers.

Stonewood Farm is a family-owned farm in Orwell, featuring humanely raised turkeys who are given a vegetarian feed containing no antibiotics, hormones or animal byproducts. They have been raising turkeys for more than 30 years and guarantee USDA certified “Humane Care & Handling” of the 34,000 birds they process every year in uncrowded, open-sided barns providing fresh air and natural sunlight.
Stonewood Farm turkeys are $3.29/lb for member-owners and $3.79/lb for nonmembers.

Our Co-op made pies are fresh baked and made-from-scratch using organic and local ingredients. These pies are perfect for your holiday gathering. There are three ways to place your pie order: now until Monday, Nov. 16, fill out our online pie order form, call us at (802) 223-8000, or order in person at the customer service desk or at the deli counter. To guarantee the freshest possible pies, we ask that you specify the day you wish to pick up your order. Orders may be picked up at the deli counter from 9 am to 7 pm on Sunday, Nov. 22 through Wednesday, Nov. 25.

Pies are available in three different varieties:
Pumpkin: $19.99
Apple: $19.99
Pecan: $23.99