Cheese Club

How it Works

Each month you order our Cheese Club box you will receive access to special cheeses with limited availability that are not regularly available in the store.
Fill out the form below to preorder the Cheese Club box of the month.
Each Cheese Club box is $60. More than one box may be purchased by adjusting the quantity.
Payments processed via PayPal. You do not need a PayPal account to make a purchase.
You will receive an email from us detailing the month’s selections and pickup dates and sent a reminder as the pickup date approaches.
Pick up at the Co-op’s cheese counter.
See our FAQ for detailed Cheese Club policy.

May's Cheese Club Selection

This box is a tasty selection of cheeses from the western reaches of the United States.

Dry Monterey Jack – Produced since 1931 by Vella Cheese Company in Sonoma County, California, Dry Jack is a true American original. Made using pasteurized Holstein and Guernsey cow milk, this cheese has the flavor and texture similar to medium-aged Parmesan, making it great for grating or shredding on pasta.
Fennel Blue – Point Reyes Farmstead Fennel Blue resembles their popular Bay Blue that has been infused with fennel seeds. Produced in Point Reyes Station, California, using pasteurized Holstein cow milk, Fennel Blue is mild with a hint of fennel sweetness, while showcasing the beautiful earthy, umami flavors of their classic Bay Blue cheese.
Teahive – Produced in Northern Utah by Beehive Cheese Company using pasteurized Jersey cow milk, Teahive is an aromatic cheddar-style cheese. Hand rubbed with a mixture of black tea and bergamot orange on day one, it is then allowed to mature for eight months where it develops a rich, milky flavor with a delicate aroma of orange blossoms.

Ordering: Apr 28–May 12 | Pickup Dates: May 26–28

Monthly Selection of Curated Cheese

Explore a wide range of flavors and styles from both local and international sources. Each month you will receive three cheeses, equaling a minimum of 1½ pounds. These will be cheeses we don’t typically carry in the store, chosen by our trusted Cheesemongers. You will also receive special additions to enhance your experience, such as jams, honey, crackers, spiced nuts, whimsical gifts, and other surprises.

Cheese Club ordering has now closed. Check back for next month's Cheese Club.

Get cheesy with us! Join the Cheese Club today.

Cheese Club FAQ

Each month you order our Cheese Club box you will receive access to special cheeses with limited availability and not regularly available in the store. You will receive an email from us detailing the month’s selections and pickup dates and sent a reminder as the pickup date approaches. Pick up your box at the Co-op’s cheese counter.

You will receive three cheeses, equaling a minimum of 1½ pounds, along with featured cheese info sheets and pairing recommendations.

When you purchase a Cheese Club box, we collect payment at checkout before fulfilling your order. Currently, we do not have a subscription option for our Cheese Club. One-time payments can be made through the form above via PayPal for that month’s Cheese Club cheeses. You do not need a PayPal account to purchase a cheese box.

Store and membership discounts are not applicable to Cheese Club orders.

We do not accept returns, refunds, or exchanges on Cheese Club purchases. Since cheese is a perishable item, we strongly advise opting into email Cheese Club pickup reminders. We are not responsible for spoiled product due to forgotten orders or late pickup.

How it Works

May's Cheese Club Selection

Monthly Selection of Curated Cheese

Cheese Club FAQ

How Does it Work?

What is Included in My Cheese Box?

Cheese Club Payments

Returns and Refunds